Transcript
below:
China perspective, 10/26/05
"Never in the history of mankind have so
many been lifted out of poverty in so short of
time." This accolade about today’s
China has been said so often that I’ve lost
track of who said it first. No matter who said
it first, much of the credit for China’s
accomplishment should go to America’s consistent
policy towards China.
For more than 30 years, America’s worked
to cajole the country out of isolation and into
the world community. Tentative at first, China
has since adopted some of the principles that have
made America great--principles such as freeing
trade, opening markets, welcoming of foreign investments,
and unleashing entrepreneurialism. China’s
undeniable success should be a cause of celebration
because China is a confirmation that the principles
we hold dear really do work. China’s success
should not be a cause of anxiety nor rueful envy.
Through its productive and low cost labor, China
has become the factory for the world. The benefit
to American consumers is consistent quality goods
at low and constant prices. China has taken most
of its trade surplus and invested in U.S. treasury
bills. Both factors keep inflation at bay in America.
China can’t be blamed for not buying from
America. Even as China’s global trade increases
by leaps and bounds, its imports and exports are
in relative overall balance. China buys roughly
twice as much from Japan and from Europe than they
buy from America. The question should be why are
we not selling more, not why are they not buying
from us.
China should not be blamed for our deficit either.
Year in and year out, China has accounted for roughly
25% of our total trade deficit. Sure, our trade
deficit with China has been growing at a phenomenal
rate, but so has our total national deficit. Again,
we should be asking what is wrong with our national
policy, not what China is doing to us.
The accusation that makes no sense whatsoever
is currency manipulation. China pegged their renminbi
to the dollar about a decade ago. The dollar was
strong then. Surely the critics are not suggesting
that China could have looked long into the future
and anticipated the downward slide of the dollar.
Today, even if China were to float their currency,
the cost differential is so large that it’s
not going to bring back jobs that have long gone
offshore.
On a recent public television program about China,
the spokesman from Wal-mart said that only in China
do they see the possibility of replicating the
success of another U.S. China’s economy is
doubling every 7 to 10 years and there is ample
opportunity for the two major powers to develop
a win-win relationship. To denigrate China, to
accuse of China of evil intentions and to drive
China toward to a lose-lose arrangement is a tragic
outcome we all should avoid. For Pacific Time,
this is George Koo
|