FT
WEEKEND MAGAZINE -
ARTS: Minority matters
By Barbara Koh
Financial Times
Aug 13, 2005
The Bush administration grumbles
about a Chinese military build-up and the renminbi's
value. Hollywood
nags about pandemic DVD piracy. US clothing manufacturers
are outraged by the influx of Chinese underwear
and shirts. Talk of the China threat worries
everyone from diplomats to investors - and the
playwright David Henry Hwang.
But while most Americans would cite China's military
might or trade imbalance, Hwang is anxious because
America's foreign relations colour its domestic
race relations. Asian-Americans are dangerously "vulnerable
to shifts in perceptions of China", says the
author of the 1988 Tony-winner M. Butterfly. Fear
of China has been voiced in the comment pages of
US newspapers, but it is a central issue in Hwang's
artistic productions.
Hwang is winding up a visit to Shanghai, during
which he has been absorbing its "youthful
internationalism" and speed-of-light transformation.
Hwang, a Los-Angeles-born Chinese-American, describes
his week in China's wealthiest, most modern city
as "a high". Tonight, though, he is preoccupied
with something more sombre and familiar: Asian-American
life.
That has been the enduring theme of Hwang's precocious
career. While majoring in English at Stanford,
he wrote his first play, FOB ("fresh off the
boat"), which won a 1981 Obie award. In Golden
Child, M. Butterfly, Family Devotions and elsewhere,
Hwang examines the interaction between identity
and history, illusions, realities and stereotypes.
He is the only Asian-American dramatist whose work
has made it to Broadway.
The correlation between US opinions of Asian-Americans
and its opinions about China stems from a tendency
to lump Asian-Americans with Asians who are "fresh
off the boat", says Hwang, 48. "We're
still perceived as perpetual foreigners" -
and thus the loyalty of Asian-Americans to the
US is doubted more than other minority groups,
he says.
He has the experience to prove it. With China's
increasing strength in the late 1990s, President
George W. Bush dubbed China a "strategic competitor".
Washington accused Beijing of acquiring sensitive
US military technology and illegally financing
Democratic campaigns, including that of the presidential-hopeful
Al Gore. Chinese-American scientist Wen Ho Lee,
allegedly a spy for China, was jailed. Meanwhile,
Far East National Bank, an Asian-American community
bank founded by Hwang's father with its headquarters
in Los Angeles' Chinatown, was scrutinised for
transactions of funds from China. Officials suspected
money laundering, perhaps to fund Chinese intelligence
operations or Democratic candidates or to buy technological
secrets.
Ultimately, no charges were brought against the
bank. But Hwang believes the episode shows how
readily anti-China hysteria, or "yellow peril",
can erupt, and "anyone who is Chinese-American
can end up being drawn in". He notes that
the reporter who broke the Wen Ho Lee story also
broke the story about the bank. Hwang's father,
who was born in Shanghai and immigrated to the
US five decades ago, felt that "Chinese can
only rise so far in this society." Finally,
the attacks of September 11 2001 "distracted
America from building up China as its next enemy" and
yellow peril subsided.
The yellow peril trauma is the backdrop to Hwang's "faux
autobiography" and newest play, Yellow Face.
Just as As You Like It and Twelfth Night play on
gender mix-ups, Yellow Face is a comedy of racial-identity
errors. (Hwang took on gender-bending in M. Butterfly,
tracing the true tale of a French diplomat's love
affair with a Peking opera diva who proves to be
both a spy and a man.) The racial muddle in Yellow
Face starts when Hwang's character mistakenly casts
a white actor, Marcus, in the role of an Asian.
Marcus loves his new racial look, even becoming
an Asian-American community activist - only to
be ensnared in the yellow peril outbreak. Eventually
Hwang realises his miscasting, but he and Marcus
fear losing face if they confess.
Hwang's character is "the butt of a lot of
the play", says the playwright. The real Hwang
led an Asian-American uproar when the Welsh actor
Jonathan Pryce was cast as the Eurasian lead in
the 1991 Broadway opening of Miss Saigon. (Pryce
had performed the role of the Eurasian pimp in
the previous West End production.) "If Asians
don't get to play Asians, what do they get to play?" Hwang
says. He believes that casting decisions are ultimately
up to the director ("artistic freedom trumps
all other things"), although dissenters should
be able to protest as loudly as they wish.
The Miss Saigon brouhaha generated dilemmas for
Hwang as an Asian- American role model, which he
expresses via Marcus. "It's a little bit arbitrary,
in the sense that I could be anybody. I happened
to achieve some visibility in a field [playwriting
and literature] that Asians weren't that associated
with," says the unassuming and mindful writer.
"But why does that give me the privilege
or responsibility to represent a community? It's
as arbitrary to thrust it upon Marcus as it is
to thrust it upon me." The characters blur. "Who's
the autobiographical character? Is it me or is
it Marcus?" Hwang says. "They become
two sides of the same coin."
It is difficult to be a role model, Hwang adds
- audiences can be demanding. Once you're cast
as a representative, people may comment that your
writing and perspective don't feel authentic to
them. "There is no one authentic vision -
there are multiple visions," says Hwang. "The
best is to have a lot of people [in the community]
writing."
As a meditation on identity, Yellow Face, set
to open in New York's 2006-07 season, also reveals
Hwang's makeover since FOB. "When I was in
my twenties, there was almost this idea 'I am Asian-
American, therefore I am' - that is, discovering
you're Asian- American was the key to understanding
yourself. But it's not," Hwang says. Now, "I'm
less devoted to being Asian-American." At
times, he's even concerned that the title "Asian-American
writer" has pigeonholed him. (A glance at
his repertoire - penning librettos for Philip Glass
operas, co-authoring a song with Prince, writing
the books for Broadway musical versions of Aida
and Tarzan - would seem to refute that.) Hwang
challenges the pervasive reflex to label minorities
by their race or ethnicity, rather than by other
criteria such as occupation, age group or neighbourhood,
or not to label them at all. "Why is it that
only if you're a minority, does the factor of your
ethnicity tend to get attached to your description
a lot?" he says. "What does it say...
if [people] believe that my most important attribute
is my ethnicity? That that's the thing that tells
the most about me?"
Hwang now has "a greater appreciation for
humanism and interculturalism", he says. "In
the best possible world, your culture should not
have to bear any relationship to your genetic make-up.
If you happen to be attracted to a particular culture
which isn't the one that's in your gene pool, you
can [adopt] that, because culture doesn't equal
race [and] race doesn't equal culture." In
an ideal world, he says, "James Earl Jones
can be cast as George Washington. Jonathan Pryce
can be cast as a Vietnamese pimp."
How does Hwang identify himself? With "various
labels", he says. "I don't ultimately
know the answer. [My] work is about asking that
question... It's in the asking that you learn something
about where you are, who you are, at a particular
time."
One reason Hwang is "less fundamentalist
about identity" is because he has young "mixed-race" children.
Hwang's actress wife is German- European. Their
son doesn't have Asian looks; their daughter does.
The playwright surprised everyone, especially himself,
when he realised he did not want to start talking
race with the kids, which he ascribes to the invariable "improvising" element
of parenting. "You have these theories about
how you are going to raise kids, and when your
kids finally show up, you're just laying track
in front of the train," Hwang says, breaking
into his first grin of the night. "It's really
nice that they have a period in their lives when
race is not an issue," he has decided. "So
I've been waiting for them to bring it up."
Hwang's personal interpretation of Asian-Americanism
is also shifting. Some 25 years ago, "when
I started being an Asian- American, it was so important
for us to be American, not Asian, not from the
root culture," he notes. Now, as Asians and
Asian- Americans increasingly criss-cross east
and west in birth, schooling and work, "there
is much more acceptance of the blurring of lines."
Hwang's heightened curiosity about the Asian half
of his Asian- Americanness prompted this Shanghai
visit. Over the past few years, "all of the
interesting east-west work has been done here",
he says. Having allowed Western producers such
as Cameron Mackintosh to bring in a smattering
of shows (including The Phantom of the Opera earlier
this year and Les Miserables in 2002), China is
now anxious to create homegrown musicals, on which
Hwang has offered to help.
He also hopes local theatre troupes will try out
his plays ("I'd love to see what real Chinese
people think [of them]," he quipped during
a public talk in Shanghai). In particular, Obie-winning
and Tony-nominated Golden Child (about Hwang's
great-grandfather in south China, his three wives
and his embrace of Christianity and modern ideas
in the early 1900s) and The Dance and the Railroad
(about two Chinese immigrants in the 1860s building
the US transcontinental) would be suitable for
a Chinese stage, he thinks. The breakthrough hit
M. Butterfly might be too pointed for China now,
but Hwang anticipates that in a few years the culture
will catch up with the play.
This is "a unique moment in history" for
US-China relations, Hwang says. Both countries
have lots of money and mutual interest and are "circling,
but still know very little about one another. This
permits individuals from either country to travel
to the other and represent themselves as more significant
than they were" - possible fodder for a fun,
Glengarry Glen Ross-type play, he adds.
On a larger scale, in what Nicholas Kristof of
The New York Times calls "the most important
diplomatic relationship in the world", misrepresentation
and misperception can fuel no-joke jingoism and
conflict. As China's power grows, so does the likelihood
that "the US will come to perceive it as an
enemy, which could trigger a yellow peril hysteria," Hwang
says. That's a real replay of Yellow Face he doesn't
want to see.
|