Commercial
Crossroads
Forbes Magazine
By Robyn Meredith
Jan. 09, 2006
A century on, Hong Kong's Li & Fung is an
increasingly vital bridge between East and West.
The Fung brothers are at the top of their game.
Tucked away in an anonymous building in what's
left of Hong Kong's garment district is a pretend
American shopping mall: There's a mock Disney
store next to the Bed, Bath & Beyond shop
and a Restoration Hardware storefront down the
hall from the Cracker Barrel Old Country Store.
All these and many more mainstream mall brands
are on display halfway around the world from
American shoppers because the faux mall serves
as a customer showroom for Li & Fung, the
$6 billion Hong Kong trading and logistics firm
that has become the go-to company for globalization.
Brothers Victor and William Fung have propelled
a family company into a professionally managed,
behind-the-scenes behemoth linking American and
European consumers to factories in 40 countries.
A stellar 2005 has made them FORBES ASIA's Businessmen
of the Year.
"After 100 years, we have become the example
of the next generation of companies, coming from
Asia with a Chinese heritage, that are able to
operate in the new globalized world," says
Victor, 60, the chairman. "Asia is coming
in a big way, and we happen to be at the right
place at the right time."
Net income in the first half of 2005 rose 23%
to $79 million. Revenue rose 19% to $3 billion.
Since 1992 the company's compound annual rate
of growth has averaged 22% for revenue and 23%
for net profit. Yet 2004's dividend yield was
3%--unusually high for such a fast-growing company.
"They've ridden the tide of the interconnectedness
of today's world," says HSBC Holdings' chairman,
Sir John Bond, who has long known both Victor
and managing director William--who is on the
HSBC board--and knew their father when he ran
the company. "They've transformed it from
the quintessential family business to a world-class
company."
Other Hong Kong business leaders admire the
Fungs' deeds. "Supply-chain management with
China as the focus has remade the face of world
trade," says David Li, chairman of the Bank
of East Asia.
Once a simple trading outfit paid to connect
buyers and sellers, Li & Fung is now at the
crossroads of global trade. In the past ten years
it has grown from $1.2 billion to $6 billion
in revenue, and analysts are banking on its $10
billion goal by the end of 2007. With sophisticated
practices the Fungs have been able to boost commissions
as a supply hub from 3% to between 5% and10%
even as volume rose dramatically.
"A decade ago we were order-takers," Victor
says. "Now, as retailers increasingly use
private labels, we advise them what items to
add at what price points and how it is displayed.
We help flesh out the alternatives to realize
their goal. We were a small part of their import
department before, and we are now a part of their
merchandising and product development and their
management thinking."
The Fung brothers leave it to other companies
to create and manage brands and to own factories
that churn out goods. The Fungs don't own the
outlets where goods are sold, either. But Li & Fung
is well on its way to doing every step in between
for its clients: designing a product, sourcing
the materials and parts for the product and choosing
the factories where it will be built, transporting
the goods across borders and arranging customs
clearance for wares packed so they are ready
to put on store shelves. In other words, a virtual
factory, virtual warehouse and virtual distributor,
with the fee depending on the level of involvement.
But it is going one step further. Part of its
evolution from middleman to supply-chain cog
is a big push into the brand licensing business.
Li & Fung licenses Levi Strauss Signature,
Levi's Red Tab, Cannon, Royal Velvet and Disney
plush toy brands. It designs, produces and delivers
their products. The idea is that Li & Fung
will produce those brands under license and sell
them directly to only the biggest big-box retailers
in the West--the Wal-Marts, Targets, Kohl's and
other hypermarkets. For example, Li & Fung
hires factories to make Royal Velvet towels and
sells them to department stores in the U.S. The
company is counting on this licensing business
growing by 2008 to 10% of revenue--$1 billion--up
from $80 million in 2004 and zero in 2002. It
may hit those goals fast: Li & Fung has partnered
with one of the bidders for Tommy Hilfiger Corp.,
estimated to sell for around $1.7 billion. The
Fungs would source Hilfiger-branded goods and
perhaps license the brand from the new owners. "We've
remade the exporters' business" by acting
as a virtual factory, Victor says. "Now
we want to remake the importers' business."
And that is just the listed arm of the company,
called Li & Fung Ltd. The two brothers, both
billionaires, each own 20% of it. (Victor is
a U.S. citizen and also appears on the Forbes
400 list of richest Americans; William holds
British and Hong Kong passports.) They own equal
shares of the parent, a holding company called
Li & Fung (1937) Ltd. The private company
has a range of other projects. For instance,
while the listed company focuses on exports from
China, the private company sells goods in China--including
toys through the Toys "R" Us Asia franchise
and sundries through the Circle K franchise it
owns in China.
While Li & Fung is still hardly a household
name in the U.S., 3.7% of America's clothing
imports--$2.7 billion worth--come through it
alone. China is a huge part of the sourcing (see
chart, p. 41), but the company's presence is
felt acutely elsewhere as well. It is Turkey's
largest clothing exporter. A quarter of Vietnam's
apparel exports flow through Li & Fung. The
far-flung empire entails connections that can
have spinoff virtues. During the SARS epidemic
the company kept Chinese shipments going by using
advanced video hookups instead of in-person meetings,
something Li & Fung's 7,000 employees plan
to repeat if there is a bird flu outbreak.
While clothing makes up 65% of the exports Li & Fung
facilitates, it sources "anything you see
in a department store," says Bruce Rockowitz,
president of Li & Fung Ltd. He was chief
executive of competitor Colby International,
which the Fungs bought in 2000. "There's
nobody else where you can get one-stop shopping
for all product categories in all countries," he
maintains.
The Fung brothers have to be experts in the
increasingly complex dance of factories, shippers
and merchandisers. Add to those some often unwelcome
partners--government officials of both consumer
and producer nations who persistently enact and
revise the rules under which global suppliers
must operate.
Because of its size and track record Li & Fung
typically benefits from such uncertainty--as
happened last year when global clothing and textile
quotas were scheduled to be eliminated for WTO
member nations. Li & Fung advised its clients
to keep shipments from China stable, just in
case countries alarmed by a surge in clothing
exports from China slapped restrictions on imports.
Sure enough, Europe and America got into spats
with China that took months to resolve, stranding
boatloads of clothing at sea. Li & Fung's
clients were mostly unscathed.
Li & Fung was formed a century ago in Canton--today's
Guangzhou--by Victor and William's grandfather
Fung Pak-liu, whose portrait hangs in the headquarters
lobby. Because Fung spoke English, he and a partner,
Li To-ming, were able to start selling porcelain,
antiques and handicrafts for export. Most of
the family, and the company, moved back and forth
between China and Hong Kong, first when trade
was interrupted by the Japanese occupation of
Canton, then with the Japanese occupation of
Hong Kong and the end of World War II. Co-founder
Li retired and sold to the Fungs in 1946.
When the Communists won China in 1949, the Fung
family lost its Chinese property, and the company--then
run by Victor and William's father, Fung Hon-chu--lost
its role as the go-between to the West as China
turned inward. "My father had to reinvent
the company," William says. "We lost
our raison d'être." With Chinese refugees
flooding across the border, factories sprang
up all over Hong Kong, and the then British territory
replaced China as the source of Li & Fung's
wares--firecrackers, plastic flowers, rattan
furniture, toys and clothes.
Victor and William had been sent off to college
in the U.S.--Victor earning bachelor's and master's
degrees in electrical engineering from MIT and
a Ph.D. in business economics from Harvard, and
William earning a degree in engineering from
Princeton and an M.B.A. from Harvard. When his
father was 61 years old, "there was a frantic
phone call from my mother, saying if one of you
guys doesn't come back and help, your father
is going to kill himself working," William
remembers. That was in 1972, when dad was immersed
in public affairs in the colony and the company
had sprawled into a family-run conglomerate.
Both brothers wanted to stay longer in the U.S.,
but William headed home: "Victor talked
me into it by saying, ‘You really should
test all the theories you learned as an M.B.A.'" Victor
stayed in the U.S., teaching at Harvard Business
School before returning to Hong Kong in 1973.
Their father, who never had a chance to go to
college, had a reverence for education and asked
William and Victor to study the company and tell
him how it should be run. They treated it as
a Harvard case study. "The first thing Itold
my dad was that Harvard Business School told
me all about family companies. I looked around
and saw all my aunts and uncles," William
says, shaking his head. (He and Victor have 35
cousins.) "Here was this 23-year-old brash
punk of a kid, and I was telling him I didn't
like the business." Yet his father bought
into William and Victor's plan to professionalize
by taking the company public in 1973, allowing
nonactive family members to cash out. In 1989
the brothers led one of Hong Kong's first management
buyouts. They relisted the company in 1992 in
Hong Kong, paying down debt from the leveraged
buyout.
Both brothers had read In Search of Excellence,
the seminal management tract of the 1980s, and
resolved to sell off various unrelated businesses
the company had acquired. There was insurance,
real estate--even chartered boats. It was all
sold off with this goal in sight: "We wanted
to reinvent the trading company," William
says.
Victor has focused on strategy and William on
operations. "V is for vision, W is for work," William
jokes. "There's a lot of give-and-take and
back-and-forth," says Victor, but "I
can think of no better partner than William.
He's fantastic in execution." The Fungs
live in the same apartment building and follow
the Chinese tradition of gathering for lunch
every Sunday.
The company remains a Chinese company with Western
characteristics. "We really have developed
a unique approach to business, which combines
East and West," Victor says. "Our methods
are very Western--what we learned at Harvard
Business School--but our values are very Eastern.
We value relationships and entrepreneurship." It
uses three-year plans to lock in goals for managers
to meet. When travel schedules permit, the brothers
meet together with important customers, to get
to know them.
One is hip-hop clothing company Ecko. It had
struggled with shipping times for two years as
it tried to satisfy a fickle clientele demanding
the freshest fashions. Li & Fung helped speed
that process after Ecko outsourced its purchasing
office to the Hong Kong company, but first Victor
and William had to get acquainted with the edgy
founder, Marc Ecko. "What influences your
designs?" Victor asked.
"It is music, it is Eminem," Ecko
said.
"Really?" Victor said skeptically,
after a long pause. "M&M?"
William began to laugh.
The professorial Victor is the more serious
of the two. He prefers to be called Dr. Fung,
is chauffeured around Hong Kong in a black Mercedes
S-Class sedan and holds a number of prestigious
civic appointments. William drives himself in
a silver Mini and trains for marathons by running
on a bamboo-and-palm-lined jogging path with
a view of Hong Kong's harbor--where container
ships loaded with made-in-China goods start their
journey to Li & Fung's customers.
In a rough-and-tumble business their company
has kept its integrity intact. That's vital when
so much commerce relies on trust. And that's
not the only way in which Li & Fung can boast
of a good name. In Cantonese it is pronounced "Lay
Fung," without the ampersand. That's because
the Chinese characters for the two family names
translate to "plentiful profit." |